If you’ve walked past your rain barrel and caught a whiff of something foul, you’re not alone. 

Smelly rain barrel water is a common problem, but it can—and should—be addressed. The last thing you want is to open your spigot and be greeted by a sulfuric, rotten-egg stench or stagnant water that smells like decay.

So, what’s causing the odor?
More importantly, is it still safe to use for gardening? 

Could it be harming your soil, your plants, or even your health? I’ve spent decades answering these questions, and today, we’re tackling them head-on.

This guide breaks down the most common reasons rain barrel water starts to stink, whether or not it’s safe to use, and—most importantly—how to fix it. 

With a few simple maintenance strategies, you can prevent bad smells from returning and keep your rainwater fresh, clean, and usable for your rain garden. 

Let’s dive in.

Common Causes of Smelly Rain Barrel Water

If your rain barrel water smells like rotten eggs, swamp gas, or a stagnant pond, there’s a reason for it—and a solution. The root cause usually comes down to organic decay, bacteria, or contamination from your roof. 

Here’s what’s likely happening inside your barrel:

1. Organic Matter Accumulation: The Silent Decay

Your rain barrel isn’t just collecting water—it’s also collecting whatever washes off your roof. Leaves, pollen, twigs, and dirt can make their way in, and as they sit submerged, they start to break down. This decomposition process releases foul-smelling gases, making your rain barrel smell like a compost pile gone wrong.

2. Algae Growth: The Green Menace

Sunlight is great for your garden, but when it hits your rain barrel, it fuels algae growth. Algae thrive in warm, nutrient-rich water, and as they multiply, they create that musty, earthy odor. Worse, as algae die and decompose, the smell intensifies. If your barrel is in direct sunlight, you’re giving algae the perfect breeding ground.

3. Anaerobic Bacteria: The Sulfur Smell Culprit

One of the most common complaints I hear is, “Why does my rain barrel smell like sulfur?”

That rotten egg smell comes from anaerobic bacteria—microbes that thrive in oxygen-deprived water. When organic matter settles at the bottom and starts to decompose, these bacteria feed on it, releasing hydrogen sulfide gas. The result? A stench that makes you second-guess using your collected rainwater.

4. Spring Pollen: A Seasonal Stink Bomb

Every spring, pollen fills the air—and your rain barrel. When pollen mixes with rainwater, it clumps together and starts to break down, creating a musty odor. If you notice your rain barrel smells worse in spring, pollen buildup is likely to blame.

5. Roof Runoff Contaminants: More Than Just Water

Your roof isn’t just catching rain—it’s also collecting dust, bird droppings, mold spores, and even chemicals from shingles. When rain washes all of that into your barrel, it introduces compounds that can lead to foul-smelling water. Some roofing materials even leach chemicals that, over time, can alter the water’s odor.

When you first catch a whiff of foul-smelling rain barrel water, your immediate thought might be, Is this still safe to use? The answer depends on where and how you plan to use it. While unpleasant odors don’t always mean the water is harmful, certain precautions should be taken—especially when it comes to your plants, soil, and personal safety.

Safety for Plants: Use With Caution

In most cases, smelly rain barrel water is still safe for watering plants—but not all plants are created equal. If your rainwater has a mild odor due to pollen or organic matter decay, it’s unlikely to harm your garden.

However, if the smell is strong and putrid (like rotten eggs), it could indicate anaerobic bacterial activity, which may introduce unwanted pathogens.

• Edible Crops: Avoid using foul-smelling rainwater on vegetables like lettuce, spinach, or any crop where water comes into direct contact with the edible portions. These plants are more susceptible to bacterial contamination, which could pose a health risk.

• Ornamental Plants: For non-edible plants, smelly rainwater is usually fine, though persistent use of heavily contaminated water may affect long-term soil health.

Best Practice: Water the soil directly rather than spraying leaves. This minimizes the risk of bacteria transferring to the plant surface.

Impact on Soil Health: What’s Happening Underground?

While plants might tolerate smelly water, your soil is a living ecosystem that could be affected by what you add to it.

• Anaerobic Bacteria: If your rainwater smells like sulfur or sewage, anaerobic bacteria are likely at play. While these microbes aren’t necessarily harmful in small amounts, they can disrupt the balance of beneficial soil bacteria if regularly introduced.

• Dilution is Key: If you’re concerned about the impact on soil health, consider diluting the smelly water with fresh water before use. This reduces the concentration of any harmful bacteria.

Human Safety: Never Drink It—Ever

Let me be clear

Rain barrel water is never safe to drink. Even if it looks clean, it can contain bacteria like salmonella, E. coli, or even traces of bird droppings and chemical runoff from your roof.

Get the Do Not Drink Sticker

• Accidental Exposure: If you’re handling smelly rainwater, always wash your hands afterward.

• Children & Pets: Keep them away from drinking or playing in the water.

• Foamy or Discolored Water: If your rainwater has visible foam, a thick film, or an unusual color, it’s best to discard it rather than risk using it in your garden.

How to Fix Smelly Rain Barrel Water

You don’t have to live with smelly rain barrel water. Whether you need a quick fix or a long-term solution, here’s how to get your rain barrel back to storing fresh, odor-free water.

Immediate Fixes: Stop the Stench Fast

If your rain barrel has already developed an odor, these quick treatments can help neutralize the smell and restore the water’s usability:

• Bleach Solution: Add 1/4 cup of bleach per 50 gallons of water. This will kill bacteria and algae while remaining safe for plants in diluted amounts. Make sure to let the water sit for 24 hours before use to allow the chlorine to dissipate.

• Hydrogen Peroxide: A natural alternative to bleach, hydrogen peroxide (3% concentration) can sanitize water and eliminate foul smells without harming your plants.

• Baking Soda: If you need a quick odor fix, add a few cups of baking soda to help neutralize acidic compounds in the water. This won’t solve the root problem but can provide temporary relief.

Preventive Measures: Stop Odors Before They Start

Prevention is always easier than troubleshooting. Here’s how to keep your rain barrel water fresh from the start:

• Block Sunlight with UV Covers: Sunlight fuels algae growth, which contributes to odors. A UV-protective cover or an opaque barrel reduces light penetration and prevents algae from thriving.

• Use a First-Flush Diverter: Your roof collects pollen, dirt, bird droppings, and other contaminants before it rains. A first-flush diverter sends the first few gallons of dirty runoff away from your barrel, keeping the stored water cleaner.

• Natural Filtration:

• Barley Bales: Placing a small barley straw bale inside your barrel releases natural compounds that slow algae growth.

• Aquatic Plants: Adding floating plants like water hyacinths can absorb excess nutrients, reducing the organic matter that leads to bad smells.

• Strategic Placement: Keep your barrel in a shaded area to slow bacterial growth and algae formation.

How to Clean a Rain Barrel

Step 1: Empty and Rinse

Start by draining all the water from your barrel. If there’s sludge or debris at the bottom, tip it over and rinse thoroughly with a hose. Swirl the water around to loosen any stuck dirt.

Step 2: Scrub the Interior

Use a long-handled brush and your choice of cleaning solution:

• Vinegar-Water Mix (50:50 ratio) – Natural and plant-safe, great for routine cleaning.

• Diluted Bleach Solution (54:1 water-to-bleach ratio) – Kills bacteria and mold but requires thorough rinsing.

• Baking Soda Paste – Neutralizes odors and scrubs away grime.

Scrub all surfaces, paying special attention to corners and seams where buildup occurs.

Step 3: Sanitize for Extra Protection

For a deeper clean, use:

• Star-San (no-rinse sanitizer) – Commonly used in home brewing, it kills bacteria without harmful residues.

• Hydrogen Peroxide (3%) – A safe disinfectant that prevents future bacterial growth.

Fill the barrel partway with water, add the sanitizer, and let it sit for a few hours. Swirl or roll the barrel to coat all surfaces before draining.

Step 4: Final Rinse and Dry

Rinse thoroughly with clean water until no cleaning solution remains. Let the barrel dry completely in direct sunlight to eliminate any lingering bacteria or odors.

Invest in the Best Rainwater Collection Gear

For high-quality rain barrel accessories, filters, and expert advice, Aquabarrel has you covered. With 20 years of experience in rainwater harvesting, we help homeowners keep their systems running efficiently year-round.